Polity & Governance Practice Question›› Indian Polity ››
Electoral System
››
Proportional Representation
M
Question 1
⏱ 0
Why is the system of proportional election for election of members to Lok Sabha not chosen?
I. Difficulty for voters to understand system due to low literacy
II. Holding election is expensive
III. It promotes majority thinking and group interest.
IV. It increases the significance of individuals over political parties.
Which of the following statements is/are correct?
a. I only
b. I and II
c. II and III
d. I, II and IV
Explanation Statement I is correct: India has a relatively low literacy rate, and a complex system like proportional representation could be difficult for many voters to understand. The first-past-the-post system used in the Lok Sabha elections is simpler for voters to grasp, where they simply vote for a candidate in their constituency.
Statement II is correct: Proportional representation involves a more complex voting system and larger constituencies. This could increase the logistical and financial costs of elections, making it more expensive to implement at a national level. The first-past-the-post system is simpler and more cost-effective for organizing elections.
Statement III is incorrect: In fact, proportional representation reduces majority thinking and promotes a more inclusive system, where even smaller or minority groups can have representation. It would encourage diverse representation of different political parties and groups, as opposed to the first-past-the-post system, which tends to favor larger political parties.
Statement IV is incorrect: Proportional representation strengthens the role of political parties rather than individuals. In a PR system, the party list system is often used, where voters choose a party rather than an individual candidate, and the parties allocate seats based on the proportion of votes they receive. In contrast, the first-past-the-post system emphasizes individual candidates.
Kutos:Polity & Governance Expert
Hello! I am a Polity & Governance expert. You can ask any question or request a detailed analysis related to this topic.