Welcome to ONLiNE UPSC

Unpacking the Motion to Vacate and Protem Speaker: A Comparative Analysis

An Insight into Key Parliamentary Procedures

Unpacking the Motion to Vacate and Protem Speaker: A Comparative Analysis

  • 14 Oct, 2023
  • 487

Understanding the Motion to Vacate in the U.S. House of Representatives

The "motion to vacate" is a crucial parliamentary procedure within the U.S. House of Representatives, designed to remove the Speaker of the House from their position. This process holds significant implications for the political landscape, as it allows members to express dissatisfaction with the current leadership.

The Purpose and Process

The primary aim of the motion to vacate is to oust the existing Speaker from their role. Initiated by any House member, irrespective of party lines, this motion can be introduced as a "privileged" resolution, requiring the House's attention. Nevertheless, procedural tactics may delay its consideration.

Majority Vote Requirement

For the motion to succeed, it must garner a simple majority vote. In a historical instance, Kevin McCarthy was removed as Speaker with a vote tally of 216 in favor and 210 against. This marked a significant moment in U.S. history, being the first instance of a Speaker's removal through this method. The decision stemmed from internal party discontent over McCarthy's collaborative efforts with Democrats to avert a government shutdown.

Historical Context and Significance

Historically, the motion to vacate remains a rarely used instrument, first employed in 1910 against Republican Speaker Joseph Cannon. It was also leveraged against Republican Speakers Newt Gingrich in 1997 and John Boehner in 2015. The motion's successful execution underscores its potential to bring about substantial political change.

The Role of Protem Speaker in Indian Parliamentary System

In the Indian context, the appointment of a Protem Speaker is a vital component of the parliamentary framework, especially concerning the Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha. Understanding this temporary role helps highlight its importance in the legislative process.

Protem Speaker Appointment Process

In instances where the positions of both the presiding and deputy presiding officers are vacant, the President appoints temporary presiding officers. Known as the Protem Chairman in the Rajya Sabha and Protem Speaker in the Lok Sabha, these appointments ensure the continuity of parliamentary operations.

Responsibilities and Powers

The Protem Speaker's primary role is to facilitate the transition after a general election, including administering the oath to newly elected members and overseeing the election of the new Speaker. While the Constitution does not explicitly outline the Protem Speaker's powers, they are assumed to possess the same authority as the Speaker, enjoying equivalent rights and privileges.

Selection Criteria and Convention

Traditionally, the senior-most members are chosen for these roles, although exceptions exist. The lack of specific procedural rules for appointing a Protem Speaker adds a layer of flexibility to the process.

In conclusion, both the motion to vacate and the role of the Protem Speaker play pivotal roles in maintaining the balance and function of legislative bodies, ensuring a smooth transition of power and accountability within these institutions.

Stay Updated with Latest Current Affairs

Get daily current affairs delivered to your inbox. Never miss important updates for your UPSC preparation!

Stay Updated with Latest Current Affairs

Get daily current affairs delivered to your inbox. Never miss important updates for your UPSC preparation!

Kutos : AI Assistant!
Unpacking the Motion to Vacate and Protem Speaker: A Comparative Analysis
Ask your questions below - no hesitation, I am here to support your learning.
View All
Subscription successful!