Welcome to ONLiNE UPSC

Understanding the India-Bangladesh Border Fencing Dispute

An Examination of Security, Community, and Geographical Challenges

Understanding the India-Bangladesh Border Fencing Dispute

  • 21 Jan, 2025
  • 252

The India-Bangladesh Border Fencing Dispute

The issue of border fencing between India and Bangladesh has highlighted significant disputes related to unauthorized construction, bilateral agreements, and jurisdictional challenges. India’s primary objective is to prevent illegal migration, smuggling, and criminal activities. Conversely, Bangladesh has expressed concerns over potential violations of the 1975 border pact and the adverse effects on local communities.

Geographical Complexity

The geographical intricacies of the border, particularly in the riverine areas of West Bengal, complicate the fencing issue. Currently, 3,141 km of the total 4,096.7 km border is fenced, while certain segments remain unfenced due to logistical and diplomatic obstacles.

Reasons for Border Fencing

The primary reason for constructing fences along the India-Bangladesh border is to enhance security. This involves curbing illegal migration, human trafficking, and smuggling, which have been persistent issues. For instance, states like Assam and Meghalaya have faced challenges related to unauthorized migration, while West Bengal has been a hotspot for cattle smuggling.

Concerns from Bangladesh

Bangladesh has raised several objections regarding the border fencing activities. They argue that these activities violate the 1975 agreement, which prohibits construction within 150 yards of the international border. Additionally, concerns have been voiced about the displacement of border communities, particularly in areas like Cooch Behar in Bengal and Dawki in Meghalaya, where many homes are within the fencing zone.

Recent Escalations

Recent incidents have intensified the dispute. For example, on January 6, 2025, the Border Security Force (BSF) attempted to build fencing in the Kalirhat block of West Bengal without prior consultation, leading to protests from Bangladesh. Similarly, on January 10, villagers in Cooch Behar protested against the construction of an improvised cattle fence by the BSF. These issues were temporarily resolved through discussions.

Key Points of Disagreement

  • Distance from the Border: Bangladesh insists on adhering to the 1975 guidelines that prohibit construction within 150 yards.
  • Impact on Communities: Many homes and villages, especially in Murshidabad and Malda, are situated between the fencing and the border, complicating relocation efforts.
  • Geography: The riverine nature of the border makes physical fencing impractical, necessitating alternative security measures like patrolling and electronic surveillance.

Geographical Challenges

The India-Bangladesh border is characterized by diverse terrains, including plains, forests, and rivers. For example, the riverine border areas along the Padma and Teesta rivers are unsuitable for fencing, requiring the use of BSF patrol boats for monitoring. In Assam’s Karimganj district, frequent flooding damages fences, leading to repair challenges and increased costs.

Proposed Alternatives

In response to these challenges, the BSF has proposed employing modern surveillance technologies, such as CCTV cameras, drones, and electronic sensors, in areas where physical fencing is not feasible. In Assam’s Dhubri district, floating border outposts equipped with radar and infrared devices monitor the riverine sections effectively.

Current Status of Border Fencing

  • As of 2023, 3,141 km of the 4,096.7 km border is fenced.
  • More than 80% of the Bengal border is complete, but some areas remain unfenced due to local opposition and delays in negotiations with Bangladesh.
  • Over 900 km of the border, particularly in riverine and hilly terrains, is monitored through patrols rather than fencing.

Resolution of Disputes

Disputes regarding border fencing are typically resolved through bilateral discussions and field-level coordination between the BSF and the Border Guard Bangladesh (BGB). Regular meetings address any concerns raised by either side. For instance, following the January 2025 incidents, both parties paused construction to facilitate discussions with local communities and officials.

Broader Implications

While the fencing enhances security, it also impacts the socio-economic dynamics of border regions. Many villagers depend on cross-border trade and agriculture, which the fencing disrupts. For example, residents in Meghalaya’s Dawki region face restrictions on transporting goods across the border, adversely affecting their livelihoods.

“A secure border is not just a physical barrier but a shared commitment to peace and cooperation.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q1. Why is India constructing fences along the India-Bangladesh border?
Answer: The primary purpose of the fencing is to enhance border security by curbing illegal migration, human trafficking, smuggling, and other cross-border crimes.

Q2. What are Bangladesh’s concerns regarding the fencing?
Answer: Bangladesh objects to the fencing, citing violations of the 1975 agreement, which prohibits construction within 150 yards of the border, and concerns about community displacement.

Q3. What recent incidents have escalated the dispute?
Answer: Recent tensions arose when the BSF attempted to construct fencing in West Bengal without consultation, leading to protests from local communities and the Bangladeshi government.

Q4. How does geography complicate border fencing?
Answer: The diverse terrains of the border, particularly the riverine areas, make physical fencing impractical. Alternative measures include patrolling and electronic surveillance.

 

Stay Updated with Latest Current Affairs

Get daily current affairs delivered to your inbox. Never miss important updates for your UPSC preparation!

Stay Updated with Latest Current Affairs

Get daily current affairs delivered to your inbox. Never miss important updates for your UPSC preparation!

Kutos : AI Assistant!
Understanding the India-Bangladesh Border Fencing Dispute
Ask your questions below - no hesitation, I am here to support your learning.
View All
Subscription successful!