The Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES 2023) reveals significant shifts in the spending behavior of Indian households. One of the most notable changes is the declining percentage of income allocated to food—down to 46.4% in rural areas and 39.2% in urban regions. This trend aligns with traditional interpretations based on Engel’s Law and Bennet’s Law.
Engel’s Law posits that as household income increases, the proportion of income spent on food decreases. This does not imply a reduction in absolute spending on food; rather, it indicates greater financial flexibility for consumers to diversify their spending. Meanwhile, Bennet’s Law suggests that with rising incomes, households transition from consuming basic starchy staples to a more varied diet that includes nutrient-rich foods such as meats, fruits, and vegetables.
However, the data from the HCES 2023 complicates these traditional economic laws. Recent reports, particularly from the Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS), indicate that real income growth has stagnated, failing to keep up with inflation. This stagnation calls into question the assumption of Engel’s Law that increased income leads to decreased food expenditure proportionally.
Interestingly, while there is an uptick in spending on non-food items such as transportation, this surge appears to be driven more by inflationary pressures than actual wealth accumulation. For instance, despite rising costs in sectors like train travel and car sales, the data shows minimal growth in real income. Even essential expenditures, such as on cereals, have seen negligible nominal increases, often resulting in decreased purchasing power when adjusted for inflation.
The findings from the HCES 2023 suggest that the reduced percentage of income devoted to food does not necessarily equate to enhanced wealth or improved living standards. Instead, this shift may reflect the rising costs of other essential goods, placing significant economic strain on households. This scenario points to deep-seated economic disparities and highlights the urgent need for policies aimed at elevating household incomes and controlling inflation.
What does this mean for Engel’s Law in the context of the recent survey? While it seems that households are spending a lower percentage of their income on food, this may not signify increased affluence. Rather, it illustrates that as prices for basic necessities rise, households are compelled to allocate less of their income towards food. Thus, if Engel’s Law fails to manifest as anticipated, it may indicate that economic growth is not uniformly benefiting all demographic groups.
In conclusion, the HCES 2023 serves as a critical reminder of the complexities surrounding household expenditure and economic health. It underscores the necessity for policymakers to focus on strategies that genuinely enhance income levels and alleviate the cost of living across all sectors of society.
Kutos : AI Assistant!
