Welcome to ONLiNE UPSC

Patent Evergreening: A Barrier to Affordable Healthcare

An In-Depth Look at Regulatory Responses and Case Studies in India

Patent Evergreening: A Barrier to Affordable Healthcare

  • 04 Nov, 2024
  • 353

What is Patent Evergreening?

Patent evergreening refers to a strategy employed by pharmaceutical companies to prolong the exclusivity of a drug by implementing minor changes in its formulation or dosage. This tactic effectively prevents generic or biosimilar alternatives from entering the market, allowing companies to sustain their market dominance and keep drug prices elevated for extended periods.

Concerns Surrounding Evergreening in the Biopharmaceutical Industry

Evergreening poses significant concerns within the pharmaceutical sector, as it limits access to affordable medications. This restriction can adversely affect public health by delaying the availability of lower-cost generics and biosimilars, which is especially critical in countries like India where exorbitant drug prices can strain healthcare systems.

Indian Law and Its Approach to Evergreening

India’s Patents Act of 1970 addresses the issue of evergreening through Section 3(d), which disallows patents for incremental innovations that do not demonstrate substantial therapeutic benefits. The landmark 2013 Supreme Court ruling against Novartis’s Glivec patent application reinforced the nation’s position against the practice of evergreening.

International Perspectives on Evergreening Regulation

Globally, there are varying approaches to regulating evergreening. In the European Union, stringent regulations are in place to prevent unnecessary patent extensions, thereby promoting access to biosimilars. Conversely, in the United States, the practice remains prevalent, leading to higher drug prices due to frequent patent renewals on existing medications.

The Importance of Addressing Evergreening for Public Health

Combating evergreening is crucial for public health as it fosters competition in the pharmaceutical market. By allowing affordable generics to enter the marketplace more swiftly, access to essential medications is broadened, and genuine innovation is encouraged.

Indian Examples of Patent Evergreening in the Pharmaceutical Industry

  • Glivec (Imatinib Mesylate): In a pivotal 2013 case, the Supreme Court of India denied a patent extension for Glivec, a cancer treatment, due to insufficient therapeutic advancements, setting a precedent against evergreening.
  • Trastuzumab (Herceptin): Roche’s breast cancer medication, Trastuzumab, encountered patent challenges in India, allowing for the introduction of biosimilar versions that enhanced accessibility for Indian patients.
  • Sunitinib (Sutent): Pfizer’s Sunitinib was denied a new patent in India for a minimally altered version, thus enabling local manufacturers to produce affordable generics.
  • Tenofovir (HIV/AIDS Treatment): In 2011, Indian authorities rejected Gilead Sciences’ application for an updated Tenofovir version under Section 3(d), facilitating the emergence of generics that drastically lowered the costs of HIV/AIDS treatment.

These instances exemplify India's dedication to thwarting evergreening, ensuring a balance between fostering innovation and providing public access to affordable medicines through the implementation of Section 3(d).

Stay Updated with Latest Current Affairs

Get daily current affairs delivered to your inbox. Never miss important updates for your UPSC preparation!

Stay Updated with Latest Current Affairs

Get daily current affairs delivered to your inbox. Never miss important updates for your UPSC preparation!

Kutos : AI Assistant!
Patent Evergreening: A Barrier to Affordable Healthcare
Ask your questions below - no hesitation, I am here to support your learning.
View All
Subscription successful!