Disgorgement refers to the legal process of compelling an individual or organization to return profits acquired through illegal or unethical means. Unlike fines, disgorgement aims to eliminate any unfair financial gain from wrongful actions.
In India, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) implements disgorgement in instances of insider trading, fraud, or market manipulation.
A penalty serves as a punishment for wrongdoing, while disgorgement focuses solely on reclaiming profits that were wrongfully earned. The objective is to ensure that no unjust benefits arise from unlawful activities.
Recently, in the case involving IndusInd Bank, SEBI discovered that five senior officials sold shares based on unpublished price-sensitive information (UPSI) related to derivative losses prior to public disclosure. This maneuver allowed them to evade losses resulting from a significant decline in the bank's stock price.
SEBI calculated the amount of loss these officials avoided through their premature sales and mandated them to return that sum. The total amount to be disgorged reached approximately ₹20 crore.
Disgorgement plays a vital role in protecting investors, upholding market integrity, and deterring insider trading. It ensures that no individual benefits from confidential or unfair information, thereby promoting a fair trading environment.
The money recovered through disgorgement is typically directed to investor protection funds or allocated for investor relief, following the guidelines set by the regulatory authority or court.
“Justice is served not only by punishment but also by restoring what was unfairly taken.”
Q1. What is the primary goal of disgorgement?
Answer: The primary goal of disgorgement is to ensure that wrongdoers do not retain profits earned through illegal or unethical actions. It serves to restore financial justice while protecting market integrity.
Q2. How does SEBI determine the amount for disgorgement?
Answer: SEBI assesses the financial gains that individuals or companies realized through their unlawful actions and calculates the total amount to be returned, ensuring fairness in investor protection.
Q3. Can disgorgement be applied to other sectors outside finance?
Answer: Yes, disgorgement can be applied in various sectors where unethical practices lead to unjust financial gains, including corporate law and environmental regulations.
Q4. What happens if a person refuses to pay the disgorged amount?
Answer: If an individual refuses to pay the disgorged amount, regulatory authorities may initiate legal proceedings to enforce the recovery of funds, which can lead to further penalties.
Q5. Is disgorgement a common practice globally?
Answer: Yes, disgorgement is a common practice in many countries as a means to ensure ethical conduct in business and protect investors from illegal activities.
Question 1: What is the primary purpose of disgorgement?
A) To punish offenders
B) To return profits from illegal actions
C) To provide investor relief
D) To maintain market stability
Correct Answer: B
Question 2: Which authority in India primarily enforces disgorgement?
A) RBI
B) SEBI
C) NITI Aayog
D) Ministry of Finance
Correct Answer: B
Question 3: How does disgorgement contribute to market fairness?
A) By imposing fines
B) By preventing insider trading
C) By encouraging competition
D) By promoting transparency
Correct Answer: B
Question 4: In the IndusInd Bank case, what type of information was misused?
A) Financial statements
B) Unpublished price-sensitive information
C) Market analysis reports
D) Investor communications
Correct Answer: B
Question 5: Where is the disgorged money typically allocated?
A) Corporate profits
B) Government revenue
C) Investor protection funds
D) Legal fees
Correct Answer: C
Question 6: What action does SEBI take if disgorgement is not paid?
A) No action
B) Legal enforcement
C) Reduction of penalties
D) Public disclosure
Correct Answer: B
Question 7: What distinguishes disgorgement from penalties?
A) Disgorgement is voluntary
B) Disgorgement is punitive
C) Disgorgement focuses on profit recovery
D) Disgorgement is only for corporations
Correct Answer: C
Kutos : AI Assistant!
